Progressive Total Loss Insurance Claims Settlement
Case Overview
Progressive Direct and Progressive Preferred Insurance have entered into a class action settlement valued at approximately $15.2 million to address claims from Colorado drivers. The core issue stems from allegations that the insurer paid policyholders less than the actual cash value of their totaled vehicles.
The plaintiffs asserted that Progressive's payments were based on valuation reports that incorporated projected sold adjustments, which they claimed were improper. These actions were alleged to constitute a breach of the company's policies and its duty of good faith and fair dealing.
To receive benefits, eligible class members must submit a valid claim form by February 5, 2027. Payments are calculated as a percentage of the projected sold adjustment impact amount, which varies based on the policy type. The settlement website is COTotalLossClaim.com.
Who May Qualify
The settlement applies to Colorado residents who made a first-party property damage claim on a personal auto policy issued by Progressive Direct Insurance Company (from April 12, 2019) or Progressive Preferred Insurance Company (from December 19, 2021) through July 8, 2026, where the vehicle was declared a total loss and the payment was based on a Mitchell Instant Report that applied a projected sold adjustment to at least one comparable vehicle.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is eligible for the Progressive total loss insurance settlement?
The settlement is for Colorado residents who filed a first-party property damage claim on a Progressive Direct or Progressive Preferred auto policy between specific dates, provided their totaled vehicle payment was based on a Mitchell Instant Report using a projected sold adjustment.
What do I need to file a claim for this settlement?
Claimants must have the claimant ID or total loss claim number and PIN from their notice to file online. It is important to only file if you qualify, as submitting a fraudulent claim can harm other eligible members.